This
was a very hard book for me to read. It got off to a very slow start
and the subject matter is very difficult. The story line contains a
child abduction, spousal abuse, and other family tragedies. For me,
it was really tough going, and I don't even have any children.
This
kind of fiction might be called “reality” fiction. It is not
light and fun and people don't always live happily ever after. It is
also a novel that weighs heavy on the thinking of people and their
growth. While there is some action, I though it was actually played
down. Very meaningful action near the end of the book happens “off
screen,” so to speak. We only hear of it second hand when I would
have thought we'd be right in the center of the event. It was not the
kind of book that kept me on the edge of my seat, nor one that
compelled me to turn pages.
There
were two aspects of the character development that bothered me. One
was Sarah, the twelve year old girl who is abducted. We get to read
some of what she writes while she is being held and used as a sex
slave. What she wrote, indicating her mental attitude, just seemed
unrealistic for a girl her age. The impression I got was that she was
basically psychologically healthy during (and after) her abduction.
That did not seem right to me. I would have been very traumatized in
her situation and I think she should have been too.
The
other character that troubled me was Amanda. She's the mother
chaperon who wasn't hoovering over her own daughter and Sarah when
Sarah was tricked into being abducted. She's a counselor helping
women identify and survive spousal abuse. Yet she refuses to accept
that her own husband is abusing her. She exhibits all the
characteristic excuses she must have heard from others hundreds of
times and tried to correct. It just seemed very ironic to me.
I
did appreciate the support that was seen by church and friends when
tragedy struck. I appreciated the strength that faith ultimately
provided. And I liked the idea of the feather. Corsets used to be
made of whale bone and wouldn't bend. Women suffered. Then a fellow
had the idea of using feather bone. It bends and so could the women.
That has great significance in the survival theme of the novel.
If
you like a novel with lots of description and ruminating by the main
character, you'll like this one. If you like novels where the heroine
suffers tragedy one hopes to never encounter and ultimately manages
to rise out of it, you'll like this novel. If you like a book that
will draw out emotions of guilt and grief, you'll like this novel.
If
you've lost a child in a tragic way, I'd skip this novel. I think it
would be too hard to read without reliving all the pain and heartache
again. Cantrell does say in a Note From the Author that she wrote
this book for every person who has ever felt alone, unloved, unsafe,
or unvalued. “It is written to remind us all that we are loved, we
have worth, and we are never alone.” I didn't find that message
loud and clear but others might.
My
rating: 4/5 stars.
Julie
Cantrell is New York Times and USA Today bestselling author. Her Into
the Free won the 2013 Christy Award Book of the Year. Her second
novel, When Mountains Move, won the 2014 Carol Award for Historical
Fiction. You can find out more at http://www.juliecantrell.com/.
Thomas
Nelson, 384 pages.
I
received a complimentary digital copy of this book from the publisher
for the purpose of an independent and honest review.
No comments:
Post a Comment