data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/e3736/e37364186b66758424d45e9317cd1b0d8c8a017e" alt=""
I
would have liked to see a stronger development of most of the
characters. Elsie, the lead female, was crafted well. I had a sense
of her personality and her dreams. I thought the other characters
could have been fleshed out more, revealing more of what drove them
to their actions.
I
would have also liked more scenic descriptions of the bubbling pools
and geysers. I wanted to feel like I'd been there when I finished the
book but I did not. I would have appreciated more information about
the geology of the area too. Elsie gave geology lessons to the CCC
fellows and it is too bad Barnett did not share them with readers.
The
strength of this novel is Barnett's attention to detail. Her Author's
Note at the end of the book showed much of the content of the book
was based on historical fact. It was interesting to read about beetle
infestations and fires and the effects on the trees.
Readers
looking for a pleasant novel in an interesting historical setting
will like this one. Just don't expect to read very much about the
actual geological features of Yellowstone.
You
can read an excerpt here.
My
rating: 4/5 stars.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/a32a4/a32a43f35185125f064ce02fe8e9144c90bca434" alt=""
WaterBrook,
352 pages.
I
received a complimentary advanced reading copy of this book from the
publisher. My comments are an independent and honest review.
No comments:
Post a Comment