I
had difficulty with this memoir style biography. I found Ericka's
writing style somewhat hard to follow, events of her husband's life
interwoven with her own opinions and facts from research. I also
found the third person point of view rather odd. For example, “Rick
wants people to know...” (3924/4152)
Ericka
shares her husband's childhood experiences and the effect they had on
him. Some might say his life wasn't so bad. He had to eat stale
sugared cereals, although the milk was never sour. Some kids might
have nothing at all for breakfast. While at his grandparents, he was forced
to eat everything on his plate or it would be there the next morning
for breakfast. (1113/4152) Yep. That was my parents' philosophy too.
Rick felt unwanted in his grandparent's home. (1135/4152) Yep. I was
relegated to play in a dank basement while at my grandparent's. I had
lunch with a lady this week who had her teeth punched out by an
abusive parent. She came out of her abusive childhood a mentally
healthy woman even though she became a Christian as an adult. It
seems to me that Rick's childhood experiences were not nearly as bad
as some, from other memoirs I have read. Ericka says Rick was “a
sensitive child.” (1100/4152) Perhaps that is more telling about
this memoir than the actual circumstances he experienced.
Ericka's
account of her husband's childhood is rather detailed and I had
trouble keeping engaged with the text. It also seemed that Ericka had
an agenda in her writing as she included much commentary with the
record of her husband's early life. Some of it was about findings
from research. Some of it was about her own emotions, I think. There
was even some commentary about the Republican party.
I
felt that sometimes Ericka embellished the hardness of Rick's
childhood. She writes of Rick and his sister, “These siblings never
heard the affirmation and encouragement all little boys and girls
crave, not even from a schoolteacher or a social worker.”
(1252/4152) Really? I find that very hard to believe, that never even
once did they hear an encouraging word from a teacher. I did not like
the racial implications either. Ericka writes that, “the problems
of children like Rick [white] aren't addressed as thoughtfully as
those of racial minorities.” (1307/4152) Really? I bet there are
many who would greatly disagree with that.
In
the end, Rick is finally healing through his relationship with Jesus
and his increasingly more stable marriage to Erika. That is
encouraging.
Some
may appreciate Erika's style of writing and the very detailed account
of her husband's hard childhood, hard army experiences, failed
marriages, etc. It was okay, I suppose, but I feel the book could
have been written so as to be much more positive and encouraging for
readers.
You
can watch a book trailer and read a chapter at
http://leavingcloud9.com/.
My
rating: 3/5 stars.
Ericka
Anderson is a freelance writer who also serves as the Digital
Marketing Director at the Independent Women's Forum and as a
consultant for The Steamboat Institute. She previously wrote for, and
was the Digital Director at, National
Review
magazine. Prior to that, she was the Digital Manager at the Heritage
Foundation and worked in communications for Vice President Mike Pence
at the GOP Conference. She attended Indiana University. She lives in
Indianapolis, Indiana, with her husband and their son.
Thomas
Nelson, 272 pages.
I
received a complimentary digital copy of this book from the
publisher. My comments are an independent and honest review.
No comments:
Post a Comment